Research and publications / Race, Marketing & Markets · Macromarketing & Public Policy
Smartphone Data Reveal Neighborhood-Level Racial Disparities in Police Presence
M. Keith Chen, Katherine L. Christensen, Elicia John, Emily Owens, Yilin Zhuo
The Review of Economics and Statistics · October 2023
Abstract
Research on policing has focused on documented actions such as stops and arrests; less is known about patrols and presence. We map the neighborhood movement of nearly 10,000 officers across 21 of America’s largest cities using anonymized smartphone data. Police spend 0.36% more time in neighborhoods for each percentage point increase in Black residents. This neighborhood-level disparity persists after controlling for density, socioeconomic status, and crime-driven demand for policing, and may be lower in cities with more Black police supervisors (but not officers). Patterns of police presence statistically explain 57% of the higher arrest rate in more Black neighborhoods.